Which Girl Would Guys rather go for ?

I find that really pretty girls hardly get noticed. Which girl would guys rather go for in a school environment

Girl 1 :
Medium height( on the smaller side) , nice fringe to the side with medium length hair , average looking cute face , wears short shorts and clotehs like that , your all round cute looking girl


and i find that girls like girl 2 wont get boyfriends or guys wont take interest

Girl 2 :
long long parted at the top straight hair light brown , light brown greenish eyes , thick lips , tall tall your all round sexy not pretty exotic looking girl ?
Why is everyone choosing Girl 1 ?